The Dark Side of Gaming in Business: What are the Disadvantages of Gamification?

Adam Steele

May 10, 2023

Imagine yourself stepping onto a basketball court or into the batter's box of a baseball game. The anticipation, the thrill, the challenge - these are the feelings that a well-designed game can stir within us. This is the essence of gamification, a concept that borrows the compelling elements from games - the rules, the competition, the rewards - and applies them to non-game contexts. From fitness apps that track your daily steps to sales incentives that drive business results, gamification is all around us, subtly shaping our behaviors and choices.

While the term might sound contemporary, the underpinning idea is as old as humanity itself. Rewards, competition, the feeling of progress - these elements have been motivating us since the dawn of time. Today, we find them repackaged in the form of points, badges, leaderboards, and virtual currencies. Gamification has emerged as a powerful tool to boost engagement, motivate behavior change, and foster learning and development. But like the twist in a gripping video game, there's another side to this story - a side that's often overlooked in the excitement of the game. Are you ready to explore the hidden corners of this fascinating concept?

The Overconfidence Penalty: The Pitfalls of Gamification

Overconfidence can be a silent killer in sports. Take a soccer player who, after a series of successful penalty kicks, becomes so self-assured that they decide not to practice them for the next match. Then, when it's time for the critical shot, they miss for the first time. The parallel in the realm of gamification is the over-reliance on this tool, viewing it as a panacea for all engagement-related woes.

The Superficial Engagement Dilemma

On the surface, gamification may seem to boost engagement. Points, badges, leaderboards can indeed make an activity more enjoyable and competitive. However, the key question is - are users engaged with the task itself, or are they just attracted to the game? Picture a sales team incentivized by a leaderboard that tracks every individual's sales. The team may indeed work diligently to climb the leaderboard. But what happens when the game is over? Will they still be motivated to make sales, or was their motivation tied solely to the game? This is the dilemma of superficial engagement - it's like a sparkler, bright and exciting, but quickly fizzling out.

The Over-Competition Conundrum

Competition, another game mechanic commonly used in gamification, can also have its drawbacks. A healthy dose of competition can inspire athletes to improve their performance. Yet, an excessively competitive environment can also lead to stress, burnout, and unsportsmanlike conduct. In the gamified setting, too much competition may breed a toxic culture, where employees step over each other to win the game. It's the equivalent of a football game where players focus more on arguing with the referee than playing the game itself.

Gamification Fatigue: When the Novelty Wears Off

Finally, there's the risk of gamification fatigue. Just as sports fans may tire of watching the same play over and over, users might get bored with repetitive gamification elements. A sales team, for example, might initially be motivated by a points system. However, over time, the novelty might wear off. The once enticing points may lose their charm, and the game may start feeling like a chore. It's akin to a long tennis match that loses its excitement due to the predictable back-and-forth.

In the next section, we will delve deeper into the disadvantages of gamification, exploring the Icarus Paradox of Engagement - how the very elements designed to boost engagement can lead to disengagement if not managed properly.

What Are the Disadvantages of Gamification? The Icarus Paradox of Engagement

The Icarus Paradox, named after the Greek myth of Icarus who flew too close to the sun, refers to the phenomenon where an overused or misused strength becomes a fatal weakness. When applied to gamification, this paradox highlights how a well-intended strategy to increase engagement can, in fact, lead to its downfall.

Extrinsic Motivation Overshadowing Intrinsic Drive

In psychology, motivation is often divided into two types - intrinsic and extrinsic. Intrinsic motivation comes from within, driven by personal satisfaction and enjoyment. Extrinsic motivation, on the other hand, is driven by external rewards or punishments. Gamification, with its points, badges, and leaderboards, typically falls into the extrinsic category. Now, think of a marathon runner who initially ran for the love of the sport. But as they started participating in races with medals and cash prizes, they began running for these rewards instead. Over time, their intrinsic love for running may wane, replaced by the drive to win prizes. This is a risk in gamification too, where the focus on extrinsic rewards can potentially overshadow the intrinsic motivation to engage in a task for its own sake.

Creativity and Innovation: Casualties of the Game

Another unintended side effect of gamification is its potential impact on creativity and innovation. For a parallel, consider a basketball player always practicing the same set of moves to score points. While they might get really good at those moves, they may not be pushing themselves to try new strategies or invent new moves. Similarly, in a gamified system, people may stick to tried-and-true methods to earn points or climb the leaderboard, rather than exploring new and innovative approaches. The focus on winning the game may inadvertently stifle out-of-the-box thinking.

The Danger of a Single Metric

The last pitfall to consider is the danger of focusing too much on a single metric. In sports, this might look like a soccer team focusing solely on scoring goals, neglecting other crucial aspects like defense or teamwork. In gamification, it could be an overemphasis on a single game mechanic, like points or badges, at the expense of other meaningful engagement measures. This narrow focus can skew perceptions and behaviors, and fail to capture the full picture of engagement and performance.

With these potential pitfalls in mind, we'll now delve into some specific, unintended consequences of gamification in the next section.

Unintended Consequences: The Cons of Gamification in Real-Life Scenarios

Climbing the Wrong Mountain: Sales Performance and Gamification

Let's consider sales, where gamification is often used to motivate teams. The scenario might be reminiscent of a cycling race. Cyclists compete to reach the top of a mountain first, similar to salespeople racing to achieve the highest sales figures. But what if they're climbing the wrong mountain? In sales terms, this could mean focusing on short-term gains instead of long-term customer relationships. In the race to win the game, salespeople might push for quick sales at the expense of truly understanding customer needs, which can lead to customer dissatisfaction and harm long-term business prospects. The overemphasis on competition, like cyclists singularly focused on the finish line, might also lead to unhealthy rivalry and a toxic work culture.

Too Much of a Good Thing: Gamification in Education

Another realm where gamification has gained traction is education, where it's used to motivate students and enhance learning. But this can sometimes backfire. Think of it like a football match. A little competitive spirit can make the game exciting, but too much can turn it into a hostile battlefield. In a classroom, over-gamification can make learning feel like a constant competition, creating unnecessary pressure and anxiety among students. The focus on rewards might also shift students' attention from learning to winning, making them more likely to cheat or take shortcuts.

The Game Never Ends: Gamification and Mental Health

Lastly, there's the issue of mental health. A game is typically a leisure activity, a break from reality. But what happens when life becomes a never-ending game? This is the risk with continuous gamification. Picture an ultra-marathon runner, constantly pushing their limits. It's exhilarating at first, but can eventually lead to burnout. Similarly, constant gamification can lead to an "always-on" mindset, where individuals feel the need to continuously perform, compete, and win. This can potentially lead to stress, anxiety, and burnout, creating a significant mental health concern.

After examining these unintended consequences, let's turn our attention to ways we can mitigate these risks while still reaping the benefits of gamification.

The Balancing Act: How to Use Gamification Right

Creating a Balanced Scorecard: Sales Gamification

Returning to our sales scenario, the answer may lie in a balanced scorecard approach. While a cycling race traditionally rewards the first to cross the finish line, a balanced scorecard rewards multiple aspects of performance. In sales, this could mean rewarding not just high sales figures, but also quality customer interactions and positive feedback. It's like rewarding a cyclist not just for speed, but also for navigation skills and sportsmanship. This approach motivates team members to excel in various aspects of their roles, fostering a more comprehensive performance culture.

Fostering a Growth Mindset: Gamification in Education

In the classroom, we can shift the focus from competition to personal growth. Instead of framing the game as a football match where students compete against each other, it can be framed as a personal fitness challenge where students strive to beat their own personal records. This fosters a growth mindset, where the focus is on self-improvement rather than outperforming others. Additionally, rewards can be tied to various learning milestones, such as understanding a difficult concept, rather than just high test scores. This encourages students to value the learning process itself, rather than just the end result.

Promoting Digital Wellbeing: Gamification and Mental Health

Finally, to address mental health concerns, we can incorporate elements of digital wellbeing into gamification. For instance, just as ultra-marathon runners need rest periods, individuals should also be encouraged to take breaks from the 'game' of life. This can be achieved by designing game elements that promote balance and rest, such as rewards for taking digital detox periods or mindfulness exercises. This helps foster a healthy relationship with technology and reduces the risk of burnout.

Final Thoughts

In the grand scheme, gamification is a powerful tool that can transform mundane tasks into exciting challenges and foster motivation and engagement. However, it's imperative to apply this strategy thoughtfully and ethically. Prioritizing balance, fostering a growth mindset, and promoting digital wellbeing are key steps in this direction. By doing so, we can ensure that gamification serves its purpose without triggering unnecessary competition or burnout.

As we navigate through our increasingly digital lives, the role of gamification will continue to evolve. It's our responsibility to ensure that this evolution benefits all participants. By considering not just the short-term goals, but also the long-term impacts of our decisions, we can make gamification a tool that uplifts rather than overwhelms.

In the words of the renowned chess player and coach, Susan Polgar, "The key to success - in chess and in life - is to focus on the next move." The same can be said about the role of gamification in our lives. It's not about winning the game; it's about focusing on the next move, learning from our experiences, and continually striving for improvement.

Outfield is pioneering sales gamification software to power CRM or any tech stack. Learn how our modern approach boosts output up to 3x.


Recent Posts