Psych Motivators For Gamifying Sales: Autonomy

Adam Steele

Jul 12, 2023

Sales performance isn't solely a matter of higher commissions, more aggressive tactics, or longer working hours. Rather, it is where behavioral psychology and sports principles can harmoniously intersect to boost motivation and results. A key? Autonomy. In psychology, autonomy is a fundamental human need, deeply entwined with our intrinsic motivation. It drives our behavior, bolsters our determination, and shapes our personal and professional outcomes. Yet, how often do we consider its power in the context of sales?

Consider this - a sales environment that harnesses the motivation derived from autonomy, not through mere independence of tasks but by igniting the inherent joy of achievement. Welcome to the era of sales gamification. This approach borrows elements from the world of sports and insightful areas of behavioral psychology to shape a novel and effective sales paradigm. Rather than seeing sales as a monotonous routine, sales gamification introduces a game-like environment where salespeople have the liberty to choose their path, define their strategies, and essentially, captain their ship.

As we venture into the details of autonomy, sales gamification, and the connection between the two, we'll see that understanding and employing this concept can revolutionize the way we approach sales. It’s about crafting a sales landscape that not only brings in the numbers but also fosters a motivated, engaged, and empowered salesforce.

The Science Behind Autonomy: Unraveling Self-Determination Theory

At the heart of behavioral psychology lies a powerful, yet often underexplored, facet of human behavior: autonomy. Defined as the capacity to make choices and decisions based on personal preference and volition, autonomy sits at the core of Self-Determination Theory (SDT). Coined by psychologists Richard Ryan and Edward Deci, SDT is a broad framework for the study of human motivation and personality. It asserts that people have three basic psychological needs: competence, relatedness, and you guessed it, autonomy.

Unpacking Autonomy in Self-Determination Theory

The concept of autonomy in SDT, contrary to common misconceptions, isn't about individualism or independence. It refers to the feeling of being the agent of one's actions, of having a sense of volition and freedom in what one is doing. It's about aligning one's actions with one's authentic self, values, and interests. When we feel autonomous, we experience a higher degree of intrinsic motivation – we perform tasks because we find them inherently satisfying, not because we're seeking external rewards or avoiding penalties.

The Motivational Impact of Autonomy: Insights from Behavioral Psychology

It isn't just theory; autonomy's effect on motivation and performance has been backed by empirical evidence. One of the most influential studies in this field was conducted by Edward Deci in 1971, which revealed an unexpected side of human motivation known as the overjustification effect.

In Deci's study, participants were asked to solve puzzles, an inherently enjoyable task. They were then paid for their performance, introducing an extrinsic reward. When the reward was later removed, the participants became less interested in the task, even though they initially found it intrinsically satisfying. This experiment, thus, highlighted how external rewards can sometimes decrease intrinsic motivation, a phenomenon termed the overjustification effect.

Autonomy and Sales: A Potent Combination

So, how does this relate to sales? The conventional sales model has heavily relied on extrinsic motivators like bonuses, commissions, or competition-driven incentives. While these factors can certainly push performance in the short term, they may not foster long-term engagement or motivation. Remember Deci's study? The overjustification effect can similarly occur in a sales context. When salespeople perceive their actions to be primarily driven by external rewards, their intrinsic motivation may dwindle over time.

On the other hand, imagine a sales environment that fosters autonomy. Salespeople are provided with the freedom to choose their own goals, devise their strategies, and own their successes and failures. This environment fuels their sense of agency, ownership, and intrinsic motivation. As we'll see, this is not a pipe dream; some companies have successfully harnessed the power of autonomy to revolutionize their sales approach.

How is this achieved? One potent tool that blends behavioral psychology, sports principles, and sales performance is gamification. Let's explore how autonomy plays a significant role in sales gamification, driving motivation and enhancing sales performance.

Sales Gamification and Autonomy: The Intrinsic Motivation Factor

In essence, gamification is the application of game-design elements and principles in non-game contexts. When applied to sales, gamification can turn everyday tasks into exciting challenges, turning the monotony of repetitive sales tasks into a series of meaningful, intrinsically rewarding activities. From leaderboards, badges, and points to levels, missions, and achievement unlocks, sales gamification employs various elements to foster a healthy competitive environment, stimulate engagement, and ultimately, drive sales performance.

Incorporating Autonomy into Sales Gamification

But, how do we bring autonomy into this mix? Sales gamification is more than just a leaderboard and points. At its best, it is a platform that allows salespeople to explore their strategies, set their targets, and choose their challenges. This is where autonomy comes into play.

By allowing salespeople the autonomy to set their course, you imbue their journey with a sense of personal investment. Every victory becomes personal, and every setback a chance to revisit and refine their strategies. The drive is no longer just about meeting a sales target; it’s about overcoming a challenge they set for themselves, fostering a higher degree of intrinsic motivation and engagement.

However, the concept of autonomy isn’t solely confined to the domains of behavioral psychology or sales performance. A surprising parallel can be found in the realm of sports. Let's shift our focus to the basketball court to further understand how autonomy can enhance performance and how this principle could be applied in the sales domain.

Drawing Parallels: Autonomy in Sports and its Relevance to Sales Performance

Autonomy plays a critical role in sports, a domain where performance is the end-all and be-all. Let's examine how basketball, a sport that places a high premium on strategy and collaboration, showcases the importance of autonomy, and consider how we can apply these principles to sales performance through gamification.

Autonomy in Play: A Glimpse into Basketball Strategy

In basketball, coaching staff typically devise game plans and strategies. However, the real magic happens when players on the court are granted the autonomy to adapt these strategies in real-time based on their read of the game situation. For instance, Steve Kerr, the head coach of the Golden State Warriors, is known to often times let his players call their plays during games.

Why does this matter? When players are granted autonomy, they become active participants in decision-making. Their engagement levels rise as they share a personal investment in the outcome of the play. They are not just executing a plan; they are crafting the narrative of the game. The feeling of being in control, the ability to make decisions that directly impact the game's outcome, fuels their intrinsic motivation, propelling them to perform at their best.

Another example of autonomy at work in sports was recently showcased in the Netflix series Quarterback. In episode 4, we play witness to how Andy Reid lets Patrick Mahomes and co make up their own plays in practice on Wednesdays, which they call "The Lab". They even come up with creative names for these plays usually based on a unique aspect of the players involved in the play. Then Andy Reid will often green light these plays for the game if he likes them. Coach Reid says it’s a great way to get the guys invested.

Applying the Principle to Sales Gamification

Similar to how autonomy enhances performance in basketball, the same principle can be applied to sales through gamification. By giving salespeople the freedom to participate in choosing their targets, strategies, or challenges within a gamified framework, you can replicate the empowerment basketball players feel when they call their plays.

Think of a gamified sales platform as a virtual basketball court. Instead of points scored, baskets made, or assists given, salespeople accumulate points based on sales made, targets met, or new leads converted. They are not just players following a pre-determined script. They become strategists, deciding their game plan, choosing their targets, and devising their strategies to win. This autonomy, when paired with the competitive, engaging elements of gamification, can lead to a significant boost in sales performance.

The Impact of Autonomy on Engagement and Performance

The beauty of incorporating autonomy in a gamified sales environment lies in its impact on engagement, commitment, and ultimately, performance. Just as a basketball player becomes more invested when they are actively involved in decision-making, salespeople who choose their challenges are more likely to commit to seeing them through.

The element of choice ignites a powerful psychological response. By choosing their challenges, salespeople become emotionally invested in the outcomes, stoking the flames of intrinsic motivation. 

Now that we have looked into the parallels between autonomy in sports and its potential impact on sales performance through gamification, let's move on to practical application. How can you effectively implement autonomy in a sales gamification context? Let's explore some actionable strategies to make this happen.

Practical Guidelines: Implementing Autonomy in Sales Gamification

Understanding the theory behind autonomy in sports and its relevance to sales performance is a crucial first step. But, putting that understanding into action can be a challenging journey. In this part of the discourse, let's explore how you can apply these principles to your sales gamification strategy, and what you need to look out for as you navigate this process.

Strategies for Incorporating Autonomy in Sales Gamification

The first step to incorporating autonomy into sales gamification is providing your sales team with a sense of control. One way to accomplish this is to allow salespeople to choose their objectives from a selection of targets aligned with the overall company goals. This could range from focusing on high-ticket items, targeting new markets, or expanding sales within existing accounts.

Another strategy is to incorporate a flexible reward system. Inspired by the varying rewards in sports - from points and goals to assists and saves - you can develop a diverse array of achievements in your sales gamification program. Not all salespeople are motivated by the same rewards; allowing them to choose what they value fosters a deeper sense of personal investment in their work.

Step-by-Step Implementation Plan

Creating a sales gamification program that fosters autonomy begins with establishing clear and diverse objectives. After that, develop a variety of challenges and rewards that are meaningful to your sales team. Regularly involve the team in reviewing and updating these challenges and rewards based on their feedback and preferences.

Potential Pitfalls and Continuous Evaluation

While autonomy is potent, it isn't a panacea. It's essential to manage it correctly to avoid common pitfalls. One risk is the possible misalignment of individual salespeople's targets with the company's overall strategic objectives. Regular oversight and feedback sessions can mitigate this risk, ensuring everyone remains on the same page.

An important aspect of this autonomy-centered approach is continuous evaluation and adjustment. Use performance data and feedback from the sales team to fine-tune the gamification strategy, making changes as needed to challenges, targets, and rewards. Following a data-driven approach, like in sports analytics, can offer surprising insights to further optimize the system.

Final Thoughts

In the journey we've embarked on together through these sections, we've discovered the undeniable significance of autonomy in boosting intrinsic motivation and enhancing sales performance. These insights, once understood, have the potential to revolutionize the way you approach sales.

The autonomy advantage isn't just a nice-to-have; it's a game-changer. By embracing this approach, you're not only fostering a more engaged, committed, and high-performing sales team but also securing a significant competitive edge. In the ever-evolving landscape of sales, those who adapt and innovate are those who lead. So, dare to innovate, dare to adapt, and above all, dare to give your team the autonomy they crave.

In the words of the late Johan Cruyff, a legendary footballer and manager, whose philosophy forever transformed the sport: "Players, with their unique individual talents, are the ones to make decisions, not the coach. There's not one coach in the whole world who can do it for them." Thus, with sales gamification, it's about enabling your salespeople to make decisions, to take control of their path, and to unlock their full potential.


Outfield is pioneering sales gamification software to power CRM or any tech stack. Learn how our modern approach boosts output up to 3x.

SalesGamificationBusinessLearningBehavioral Psychology

Recent Posts